Many injured workers are concerned their employment may be in jeopardy after being injured at work. Fortunately, the Wisconsin Worker’s Compensation Act protects an injured worker from an employer’s unreasonable refusal to rehire (or discharge).
If an employer unreasonably refuses to rehire an injured worker, the employer alone (not the insurance company) must pay that worker as much as one year’s pay. The one year’s pay is a monetary limit, not a temporal one, meaning that the damages will continue to accrue after the first year if you have earned wages in the meantime. Additionally, the applicant need not show the company had a motive related to the work injury. All an applicant must do is show he or she was an employee with a compensable injury who was refused rehire or discharged. The employer then has the burden to show reasonable cause for this refusal to rehire or discharge. “Reasonable cause” is a cause or reason that is fair, just, or fit under the circumstances, judged within the specific context of a given case.
One common situation in which a refusal to rehire claim arises is where an employer has experienced a business decline and does not have available work. Such a decline may be reasonable cause for not rehiring an injured worker, assuming this reason provided is not pretextual. However, if the employer’s business improves within a reasonable amount of time and suitable work becomes available, the employer must offer a position to the employee.
The Wisconsin Supreme Court and Wisconsin Court of Appeals have held that §102.35(3) must be liberally construed to effectuate its beneficent purpose of preventing discrimination against employees who have sustained compensable work-related injuries. In addition to protecting an injured worker from discrimination, Wis. Stat. § 102.35(3) also serves to return the injured person to work with his former employer.
5 Action Steps to Follow If You Are Fired or Refused Rehire After a Work Injury
1. If refused rehire, make sure to notify your employer of your restrictions or lack thereof in writing and explicitly inform the employer that you want to return to work. Keep track of all communications.
2. If your exact position is not available when you return to work or if your position is eliminated resulting in discharge, inform your employer that you are interested in other positions.
3. Apply for unemployment benefits. These benefits will not offset any damages you receive under Wis. Stat. § 102.35(3). Additionally, information you receive from the unemployment investigation process may assist you in determining the reasons behind the employment separation. (Note: There is of course the risk that you may say something harmful to your case).
4. Keep track of the money that you make following the termination or refusal to rehire. The wages earned will offset your damages, and an Administrative Law Judge will want to see proof of these wages earned.
5. There is no explicit requirement to “mitigate your damages” under Wis. Stat. § 102.35(3), meaning there is no explicit requirement that you apply for jobs with other employers or risk a reduction of your recovery. However, not applying for other jobs may paint a bad picture during settlement discussions or at a hearing, so we recommend applying for other jobs. Also, if another employer offers you a position and you reasonably refuse that offer, document the reasons why you refused the job offer. (Note: Failing to complete a job search and refusing a job offer will have very different consequences on your unemployment benefits eligibility).
If you have been refused rehire or discharged following a work injury and would like to discuss the specific details of your situation, please contact an experienced Wisconsin worker’s compensation attorney at Hawks Quindel for a free consultation. For a recent Hawks Quindel victory in an unreasonable refusal to rehire case, see this blog post.
Latest posts by Hawks Quindel, S.C. (see all)
- HQ Attorneys Richard Saks and Michele Sumara Commence a Lawsuit against Milwaukee Voucher School for Unpaid Wages - August 23, 2016
- Attorney Charlton to Become a Fellow of the Wisconsin Law Foundation - August 17, 2016
- Attorneys Fairweather and Good to Present on Arbitration Hearings at 2016 Health, Labor and Employment Law Institute - August 10, 2016