Skip to content
Our team has decades of experience serving people across the state and throughout the country.
Madison Office: (608) 257-0040
Milwaukee Office: (414) 271-8650
Get a Free Case Screening
Hawks Quindel, S.C. Logo
  • Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
    • Workers' Compensation
    • Employment
    • Employment Contracts
    • Wage & Hour Claims
    • STD/LTD Benefits
    • Social Security Disability
    • Duty Disability
    • Employee Benefits
    • Labor Law
    • Family & Divorce
    • Criminal Conviction Record
  • Offices
    • Milwaukee
    • Madison
    • Chicago
    • Appleton
    • Waukesha
  • About the Firm
    • Firm History
    • Mission & Values
    • What to Expect
    • Community Involvement
    • Workplace Culture
    • Careers
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • News & Victories
  • En Español
    • La Compensación Laboral
    • Ley Laboral
    • Ley de Permiso de Auscencia Médica o Familiar
    • Sueldos y Salarios
  • Contact

An Uphill Battle: Understanding the “Arbitrary and Capricious” Standard of Review.

Home  >  Blog  >  An Uphill Battle: Understanding the “Arbitrary and Capricious” Standard of Review.

October 20, 2026 | By Jessa Victor
An Uphill Battle: Understanding the “Arbitrary and Capricious” Standard of Review.

The arbitrary and capricious standard of review can decide a long-term disability case before a judge ever considers your medical condition. It controls how much deference the court gives to the insurance company's decision, and in many employer-sponsored plans, that deference is considerable.

For workers who have spent decades in a career and can no longer work, knowing which standard applies shapes every choice about how to fight a denial.

Key Takeaways for the Arbitrary and Capricious Standard of Review

  • ERISA benefit denials are reviewed de novo by default, and the arbitrary and capricious standard applies only when the plan grants the administrator discretion to decide claims.
  • Under arbitrary and capricious review, a federal court asks whether the insurer's decision was reasonable and adequately explained, not whether the court would have reached the same result.
  • An insurer that both decides and pays claims has a conflict of interest that courts must weigh as a factor in reviewing its decision.
  • In the Seventh Circuit, which covers Wisconsin, an insurer that misses ERISA's deadline for deciding an appeal loses deference, and the claim is reviewed de novo.
  • A denial can be found arbitrary when the insurer ignores reliable evidence, gives vague reasons, or fails to address contrary findings, such as a Social Security disability award.

What Is the Arbitrary and Capricious Standard of Review in an ERISA Disability Case?

The arbitrary and capricious standard of review is the deferential test a federal judge applies when an ERISA plan vests discretion in the insurer to decide claims. The court will uphold a long-term disability denial unless the decision was unreasonable, unexplained, or unsupported by the record.

What Does "Arbitrary and Capricious" Mean in an ERISA Case?

In an ERISA disability case, "arbitrary and capricious" means a court will overturn the insurer's decision only if it was unreasonable. Courts also call this an "abuse of discretion" review.

The judge is not deciding whether you are disabled. The judge is deciding whether the insurer's conclusion holds up.

The Question a Judge Asks

The Seventh Circuit has described the test in practical terms.

A decision generally survives if the insurer can offer a reasoned explanation based on the evidence, relies on a reasonable reading of the plan, and considers the important aspects of the claim. A decision that skips over key evidence or gives only boilerplate reasons is far more vulnerable.

What the Standard Does Not Mean

Deference is not a rubber stamp. Courts do reverse denials that rest on a selective reading of medical records, an unexplained reversal after years of paid benefits, or reasoning that the insurer never gave the claimant.

How Arbitrary and Capricious Review Compares to De Novo Review

The standard of review works like a starting line, and the two possible standards put claimants in very different positions.

Under de novo review, the judge looks at the evidence with fresh eyes and decides whether you meet the plan's definition of disability. Under arbitrary and capricious review, the judge asks only whether the insurer's decision was reasonable.

QuestionDe novo reviewArbitrary and capricious review
When it appliesThe plan does not give the insurer discretion, or the insurer lost deferenceThe plan gives the insurer discretion to decide claims
What the judge decidesWhether you are entitled to benefits under the planWhether the insurer's decision was reasonable
Weight given to the insurer's viewNone beyond the evidence itselfSignificant deference
Effect of close callsCan be decided in your favorUsually resolved in the insurer's favor
Typical remedy if you winAn order that benefits are owedOften a remand, sometimes reinstatement

The practical difference shows up in close cases. When the medical evidence could reasonably be read either way, de novo review gives the judge room to side with you, while deferential review usually does not.

When Does the Arbitrary and Capricious Standard Apply?

reading insurance policy document glasses desk american

The arbitrary and capricious standard applies only when the plan clearly gives the claims administrator discretion. In Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Bruch, the U.S. Supreme Court held that denials are reviewed de novo unless the plan grants the administrator discretionary authority to determine eligibility or interpret the plan's terms.

Most group long-term disability policies include that language, often called a discretionary clause. It usually says something like "the insurer has discretionary authority to determine eligibility for benefits and to construe the terms of the policy."

Finding out whether your plan contains it means checking several documents:

  • The group insurance policy or certificate of coverage that was issued to your employer
  • The plan document, if your employer maintains one separate from the policy
  • The summary plan description, which ERISA requires plans to provide to participants
  • Your denial letters, which sometimes reference the standard the insurer expects to apply

If the language appears only in a summary or a letter, it is worth raising an argument with a lawyer.

Can a Discretionary Clause Be Overcome?

Yes.

Even when a plan contains a discretionary clause, several situations can lead a court to review the claim de novo or give the insurer less deference. Each depends on specific facts, so none applies automatically.

  • Missed decision deadlines: In Fessenden v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance Co., the Seventh Circuit held that an insurer that failed to decide an appeal within the regulatory deadline was not entitled to deference, and the claim had to be reviewed de novo.
  • State bans on discretionary clauses: Some states prohibit discretionary clauses in insured disability policies. Wisconsin has not adopted a ban, but a policy issued to an employer in another state may be governed by that state's rules.
  • Plans outside ERISA: Government employer plans, many church plans, and individual policies you bought yourself are not governed by ERISA's deferential framework in the same way.
  • Self-funded versus insured plans: State insurance rules generally apply to insured policies, not plans that an employer pays for from its own assets.

These exceptions are one reason the documents and timeline of a claim are worth reviewing early.

What Makes an Insurer's Denial Arbitrary and Capricious?

A denial is arbitrary and capricious when it is not the product of a reasoned, evidence-based process. Federal claims rules and court decisions point to recurring problems that can tip a case in the claimant's favor.

  • Ignoring reliable medical evidence: In Black & Decker Disability Plan v. Nord, the Supreme Court held that insurers need not give treating doctors special deference, but they may not arbitrarily refuse to credit a claimant's reliable evidence.
  • Failing to explain disagreement with other findings: Under the Department of Labor's disability claims regulation, a denial must explain why the insurer disagreed with treating providers, vocational professionals, or a Social Security disability decision it was given.
  • Vague or shifting reasons: The same regulation requires denial letters to state the specific reasons for the decision and the plan provisions relied on.
  • Overlooking what you submitted: A full and fair review must take into account the information the claimant provided, whether or not it was part of the first decision.

Individual problems may not be enough on their own. Courts often look at the whole picture, and several smaller flaws together can show that a decision was not reasoned.

How Does a Conflict of Interest Affect Review?

A conflict of interest does not change the standard of review, but it makes the insurer's decision easier to question. In Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Glenn, the Supreme Court held that an insurer that both decides and pays claims operates with a conflict that courts must weigh as a factor.

The Dual Role Problem

When the same company pays benefits out of its own funds and decides who qualifies, every approved claim costs it money.

That arrangement is common in insured long-term disability plans. The law does not assume the insurer acted in bad faith, but it treats the incentive as something a judge should keep in view.

When the Conflict Carries More Weight

The Glenn court explained that the conflict matters more when the circumstances suggest it actually affected the decision and less when the insurer took real steps to reduce bias. In that case, the insurer had encouraged the claimant to apply for Social Security benefits, benefited from the award, and then disregarded the agency's finding when it denied her claim.

What Happens If a Court Rules the Denial Was Arbitrary?

Federal courthouse where ERISA disability cases are reviewed

A finding that the insurer acted arbitrarily does not always end with an order to pay benefits.

The remedy depends largely on whether the insurer denied a new claim or cut off benefits it had been paying. Possible outcomes include:

Remand to the Insurer

When the problem is an inadequate explanation or an incomplete review of a new claim, courts often send the claim back to the insurer to decide again under proper procedures. That can mean more time, but the insurer must correct the flaws the court identified.

Reinstatement of Terminated Benefits

When an insurer ends benefits it had been paying, courts in the Seventh Circuit may order the benefits reinstated.

In Hackett v. Xerox Corp. Long-Term Disability Income Plan, the court ordered retroactive reinstatement after finding the termination arbitrary. District courts still weigh the specific facts before choosing a remedy.

What the Standard of Review Means for Your Claim

The standard of review is set by existing documents and dates, which means some of the most useful work happens early. Many people with a denied or terminated claim find it helpful to:

  1. Request the complete plan document, group policy, and summary plan description in writing from the plan administrator.
  2. Look for language that gives the insurer "discretion" or "discretionary authority" to decide claims or to interpret the plan.
  3. Keep every letter from the insurer and write down the date each one arrived.
  4. Note whether the insurer asked you to apply for Social Security disability benefits and how it treated any decision.
  5. Ask whether the plan is insured or self-funded and which state the policy was issued in.

Bringing this information to a legal consultation allows an attorney to evaluate much sooner whether deferential review really applies, and where the insurer's decision may be weakest.

FAQs About the Arbitrary and Capricious Standard of Review

Can I add new evidence once my ERISA disability case is in court?

Usually not. When a court applies the arbitrary and capricious standard, it generally reviews only the claim file the insurer had when it made its final decision. Some courts allow limited additional evidence regarding issues such as a conflict of interest or procedural problems, but new medical records are rarely accepted at that stage.

Is there a deadline to file an ERISA disability lawsuit?

Yes, but ERISA itself does not set one for benefit claims. Many disability plans include their own deadline for filing suit, and the U.S. Supreme Court has held that a reasonable plan deadline is enforceable. That deadline can start running before the insurer's appeal process ends. If the plan sets no deadline, courts typically apply a comparable state law time limit.

Can you win an ERISA disability lawsuit under the arbitrary and capricious standard?

Yes. Claimants win ERISA disability cases under the arbitrary and capricious standard when the insurer ignored reliable evidence, failed to explain its reasoning, missed required procedures, or reached a conclusion the record does not support. The standard is deferential, but it does not automatically approve the insurer's decision.

Does a jury decide an ERISA disability lawsuit?

No. ERISA claims for disability benefits are decided by a federal judge, not a jury. The judge typically reviews the insurer's claim file and the parties' written arguments rather than holding a traditional trial with live testimony.

Is "abuse of discretion" the same as arbitrary and capricious in ERISA cases?

Generally, yes. Federal courts reviewing ERISA benefit denials, including the Seventh Circuit, apply the same deferential standard to abuse of discretion and arbitrary and capricious. Both ask whether the insurer's decision was reasonable rather than whether it was correct.

Does the arbitrary and capricious standard apply to individual disability policies?

Usually not. An individual disability policy you bought yourself, outside your job, is typically not governed by ERISA. Those disputes are usually decided under state insurance and contract law, where the insurer does not receive ERISA's deferential review.

Can I get punitive damages if my ERISA disability claim was wrongly denied?

Generally, no. ERISA's claim for benefits typically allows recovery of benefits owed under the plan, and courts may award attorney fees, but punitive damages and emotional distress damages are usually unavailable in these cases.

Does the arbitrary and capricious standard apply to short-term disability claims?

It can. If your short-term disability coverage is an ERISA-governed plan with a discretionary clause, the same deferential standard generally applies. Some employer short-term disability programs are paid from general payroll rather than a separate plan, and those may fall outside ERISA.

Contact Hawks Quindel S.C. When the Standard Feels Stacked Against You

A deferential standard can make a denial feel final.

It is not. The rules that give insurers deference also set limits, and those limits are where many long-term disability claims are won.

Hawks Quindel, S.C., has represented workers, never insurers or employers, since 1959, and our attorneys handle ERISA and long-term disability claims for employees across Wisconsin.

We can review your plan documents and denial as part of a free case screening after intake review. Results depend on the facts of each claim.

Call our Madison office at 608-257-0040 or our Milwaukee office at 414-271-8650 to learn more about your legal rights.

Contact an Attorney

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Can we communicate with you via SMS (Text) message?
PLEASE NOTE: Only our Madison office can serve cases relating to Criminal Conviction Records.
Hawks Quindel is a plaintiff-side firm serving the State of Wisconsin and beyond. In order for your inquiry to be sent to the correct group of attorneys for review, please select one of our areas of practice that best categorizes your legal issue.
After receiving your initial inquiry, our attorneys may follow-up with questions relevant to the area of practice that categorize your specific legal issue.
Are you completing this form on behalf of another person?

  • Wisconsin Wrongful Termination Lawyers
  • LTD Independent Medical Exams & Insurer Investigations
  • Own Occupation LTD
  • Wisconsin Permanent Partial Disability & PPD Rating Attorneys
  • Wisconsin Severance Agreement Review & Negotiation
  • LTD Benefit Termination & Reinstatement
  • Can You Receive Workers' Comp and LTDI at the Same Time?
  • Workers' Comp for Healthcare and Nursing Staff
  • Wisconsin Warehouse and Manufacturing Worker Injury Lawyers
  • Back Injury Workers' Compensation Claims

Hawks Quindel, S.C. Logo

Get a Free Case Screening Call Us Today


Milwaukee

5150 N Port Washington Rd Ste 243,
Milwaukee, WI 53217-5470
(414) 271-8650

Madison

409 E Main St,
Madison, WI 53703
(608) 257-0040

Chicago

111 E Wacker Drive Ste 2300,
Chicago, IL 60601
312-262-7517

Appleton

54 Park Pl #400 ,
Appleton, WI 54914
920-931-2560

Waukesha

500 Elm Grove Rd Ste 205,
Elm Grove, WI 53122
262-439-4450

Attorneys|Practice Areas|About the Firm|Blog
© 2026 Hawks Quindel, S.C. |Sitemap|Disclaimer
Hawks Quindel represents clients throughout the State of Wisconsin, including the cities of Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Kenosha, Racine, Appleton, Waukesha, Eau Claire, Oshkosh, Janesville, West Allis, La Crosse, Wauwatosa, Sheboygan, Fond du Lac, New Berlin, Wausau, Menomonee Falls, Brookfield, Oak Creek, and Beloit, among others statewide. Hawks Quindel also represents Illinois clients throughout the State of Illinois through its Chicago office. In addition, our attorneys represent clients nationwide in short-term disability (STD), long-term disability (LTD), and other employee benefit claims, as well as select out-of-state Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) matters.