For fifteen years, Act 10 has limited the collective bargaining rights of most public employees in Wisconsin. Two recent events could decide its future: a July court ruling that kept the law in place, and a November election that changed who controls state government. Here is where things stand for teachers, nurses, and other public workers.
What Act 10 does
For most public employees, Act 10 limits bargaining to base wages, and it caps any raise at the rate of inflation. Since its passage, public sector employees have been deprived of the opportunity to collectively bargain over working conditions, insurance, retirement, and sick leave. Unions must now win a recertification election every year, and employers may not deduct union dues from paychecks. However, police officers, firefighters, and other “public safety” employees are exempt from these limits.
Recent court challenges
It is that exception for “public safety” employees that created the hook for recent challenges to the legality of Act 10. Several unions sued in Dane County, arguing that treating public safety employees differently from other public employees violates the Wisconsin Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection. In December 2024, Judge Jacob Frost agreed and struck down key parts of the law. He then put his ruling on hold while the case was appealed.
On July 29, 2026, the Court of Appeals reversed in a 2-1 decision in Abbotsford Education Association v. WERC. The court relied on earlier state and federal decisions that upheld Act 10. The unions have asked the Wisconsin Supreme Court to review the case. As of this writing, the Court has not announced whether it will take it. If it does, a decision would likely come in 2027; but, for now, Act 10 remains fully in effect.
The impact of the 2026 election
On November 3, voters elected David Crowley as governor and gave Democrats majorities in both the Senate and the Assembly. It will be the first time since Act 10 passed in 2011 that the party opposed to Act 10’s passing hold the governor’s office and both houses of the Legislature. While this makes a legislative change possible, but nothing is automatic. Repeal would require a bill to pass both houses. Even then, bargaining rights would not return overnight. Unions whose certification lapsed would likely need to reorganize, and changes to wages and benefits would have to be negotiated. Furthermore, it is possible that the Legislature may take action parallel to a repeal that would still affect public sector bargaining rights.
Rights public employees have today
Despite the negative effects of Act 10, public sector employees still have many rights in their workplaces. This includes:
- The right to join a union and act together with coworkers;
- Protection from discrimination and retaliation under the Wisconsin Fair Employment Act and federal law;
- Family and medical leave rights under state and federal law;
- First Amendment protection for speech on matters of public concern;
- The right to request public records;
- Worker’s compensation benefits for work injuries; and
- In many cases, civil service or “just cause” protections under state law, local ordinance, or an employee handbook.
Contact Hawks Quindel
Hawks Quindel has represented Wisconsin workers and their unions for decades. We will keep following the Act 10 litigation and any legislation in the 2027 session. If you are a public employee with questions about discipline, discharge, or your rights at work, contact us to schedule a consultation.