Skip to content
Our team has decades of experience serving people across the state and throughout the country.
Madison Office: (608) 257-0040
Milwaukee Office: (414) 271-8650
Get a Free Case Screening
Hawks Quindel, S.C. Logo
  • Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
    • Employment
    • Family & Divorce
    • Labor Law
    • Social Security
    • Employee Benefits
    • Wage & Hour
    • Workers' Compensation
    • STD/LTD Benefits
    • Employment Contracts
    • Duty Disability
  • About the Firm
    • Mission & Values
    • What to Expect
    • Firm History
    • Community Involvement
    • Careers
    • Workplace Culture
    • Offices
      • Milwaukee
      • Madison
      • Chicago
      • Appleton
      • Waukesha
  • Blog
  • News & Victories
  • En Español
    • La Compensación Laboral
    • Ley Laboral
    • Ley de Permiso de Auscencia Médica o Familiar
    • Sueldos y Salarios
  • Contact
  • Search

THE NOT-SO INDEPENDENT MEDICAL EXAM

Home  >  Blog  >  THE NOT-SO INDEPENDENT MEDICAL EXAM

February 22, 2012 | By Bill Parsons
THE NOT-SO INDEPENDENT MEDICAL EXAM

So, you were injured at work and now your employer’s worker’s compensation carrier wants you to meet with their so-called “independent” doctor. What should you expect about this appointment and what can you do to give yourself the best chance of receiving your worker’s compensation benefits? The first thing you should know is that you will be meeting with a doctor who has been paid by the insurance company. The doctor is not independent and is not there to help you with your injury. When the insurance company sets an appointment for you to see their doctor, it is usually a sign that your claim is about to be denied. This doctor will be looking for anything that calls your claim into question. For example, the doctor may question you about how the injury happened. If your story is different from how it was reported on an injury form or in the notes that your doctors took, the insurance company doctor may say that your report of the injury is “inconsistent.” If possible, review your medical records and injury reports to remind yourself how you described the injury. Make sure your description remains clear and consistent. The insurance company’s doctor may also try to describe the nature of your medical problems as a “pre-existing condition.” If you have never sought medical treatment for the injured body part prior to the work injury, make sure that the insurance company’s doctor knows this. If you have received medical treatment for the same body part - that’s ok. If this is the case, make sure to explain when that treatment was (especially if it was many years ago). If the treatment was closer to the injury at work, explain to the doctor why the injury at work felt different. Was the pain more severe? Did you hear a pop or crack that you had never heard before? These are key facts that the insurance company’s doctor must take into consideration. Beyond this, I provide my clients with the following list of tips when preparing for a meeting with the insurance company’s doctor: * Be prompt, polite and cooperative. But, also be firm. If the doctor says something you don’t agree with, make sure that you tell the doctor why what was said is false. * Be aware of video surveillance activities to and from the exam as well as any time during the duration of your claim (do not exceed any physical limitations set by your doctor at any time). * Be aware that the doctor and/or employees of the doctor’s office routinely watch your movement in and out of the exam, from the parking lot to the exam office, and exiting the building. * Answer truthfully about prior accidents or injuries if specifically asked. * Do not complete a questionnaire! * Do not sign any authorizations. * Do not answer medical and employment questions that are not reasonably related to your injury being claimed. * Take notes about the appointment. You are entitled to receive a copy of the doctor’s report. When you receive this report, review your notes from the appointment and make additional notes about the facts and opinions that you disagree with in the report. This will be valuable to your attorney in preparing your worker’s compensation case. If your worker’s compensation claim has been denied or if you would like to talk to an attorney prior to your appointment with the insurance company’s doctor, please call Hawks Quindel to speak with an experienced worker’s compensation attorney for a free, confidential consultation.

Contact an Attorney

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Can we communicate with you via SMS (Text) message?
Hawks Quindel is a plaintiff-side firm serving the State of Wisconsin and beyond. In order for your inquiry to be sent to the correct group of attorneys for review, please select one of our areas of practice that best categorizes your legal issue.
After receiving your initial inquiry, our attorneys may follow-up with questions relevant to the area of practice that categorize your specific legal issue.
Are you completing this form on behalf of another person?

  • Employment Flat Fee Consults
  • Short or Long-Term Disability Flat Fee Consults
  • Improper Classification of Salaried Employees
  • Applying for Social Security Benefits
  • How Social Security Evaluates Disability
  • SSDI vs. SSI
  • Short Term Disability Benefits
  • Long Term Disability Benefits
  • Sex & Gender Discrimination
  • Americans with Disabilities Act

Hawks Quindel, S.C. Logo

Get a Free Case Screening Call Us Today


Milwaukee

5150 N Port Washington Rd Ste 243,
Milwaukee, WI 53217-5470
(414) 271-8650

Madison

409 E Main St,
Madison, WI 53703
(608) 257-0040

Chicago

111 E Wacker Drive Ste 2300,
Chicago, IL 60601
312-262-7517

Appleton

54 Park Pl #400 ,
Appleton, WI 54914
920-931-2560

Waukesha

500 Elm Grove Rd Ste 205,
Elm Grove, WI 53122
262-439-4450

Attorneys|Practice Areas|About the Firm|Blog
© 2025 Hawks Quindel, S.C. |Sitemap|Disclaimer
Hawks Quindel represents clients throughout the State of Wisconsin, including the cities of Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Kenosha, Racine, Appleton, Waukesha, Eau Claire, Oshkosh, Janesville, West Allis, La Crosse, Wauwatosa, Sheboygan, Fond du Lac, New Berlin, Wausau, Menomonee Falls, Brookfield, Oak Creek, and Beloit, among others statewide. Hawks Quindel also represents Illinois clients throughout the State of Illinois through its Chicago office. In addition, our attorneys represent clients nationwide in short-term disability (STD), long-term disability (LTD), and other employee benefit claims, as well as select out-of-state Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) matters.